• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Pete's Pizza - New Richmond: Classic Thin-Crust Pizza with Friendly Local Service

Pete's Pizza - New Richmond, located at 1230 N Knowles Ave, is a beloved local pizzeria known for its consistently great thin-crust pizza and flavorful sauce. Customers praise the helpful staff and the warm, inviting atmosphere, even after the buffet was phased out and the dining area resized. Longtime fans appreciate its nostalgic charm and dependable quality, making it a go-to spot for family gatherings and casual outings alike. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, Pete’s preserves the authentic taste that keeps patrons coming back, blending tradition with modern convenience in the heart of New Richmond, Wisconsin.

Pete's Pizza - New Richmond at a glance

  • Address 1230 N Knowles Ave, New Richmond, WI 54017, United States
  • Phone +1 715-246-2633
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Pete's Pizza - New Richmond: Reviews & Ratings

Rhonda & Bob Haglund
5

Great pizza and very helpful staff! Support local and try it tonight!

Matt Howe
5

Great pizza. Thin crust worth amazing sauce. Ordering online is now ready as it could ever be. Still great after all these years.

Krystal Hesselink-Gaustad
4

No more buffet but still delicious pizza and food. And you can dine in again. Half the dining room size but still a good environment and the same pizza

Melanie Olson
5

Admittedly I haven’t eaten at Pete’s in years. My Grandma and well like a hundred relatives live in New Richmond and I grew up eating Pete’s take-out and their buffet. So so so many family gatherings at that buffet. I wish the inside was reopen and it functioned like a real restaurant again. -Anyways, I’m stopping by and getting take-out tonight for my trip to my grandmas, I’m excited to try it again after about 12 year break and I hope it is as good as my memories

Mary Ann nelson
5

I love pizza! But have not found the taste of pizza from the East side of Milwaukee. I think Pete’s is very close but the ingredient missing from a true Italian pizza is fennel seed.

s Orange
5

I absolutely love this place! I travel from Eau Claire... just for this pizza!! They have the best cheese curds, too! Thank you for the best pizza around!!!

Allison Wright
4

Last time I was there they were closed on Monday...then closed again on Tuesday with a sign that would be open for dinner...and they needed cooks. My coworker and I stopped here because we were hungry and there were a ton of cars in the parking lot. I was pleasantly surprised. The pizza was really good. We got a thin crust Hawaiian pizza. There was a buffet but we didn't get that. I will definitely be back the next time I am in town! I have also added it to my restaurant list for the New Richmond area!

David Gusek
5

Lived in NR for years and finally gave Pete's a try. I'm am pizza conesour so heres the rub- If you like a sweeter pizza sauce like me, 5/5 on the sauce. I havent tried any pasta dishes there, but I would hope they use a savory tomato sauce. The crust was well-cooked. I loved the crispy dark edges. 5/5 on cooking. Perfect amount of all topping. I'd prefer to have fresh ground beef rather than small crumble. Still excellent. 4/5 toppings. Pieces are cut VERY small. Thats cool, Its just a preference to have a 16" za cut 3x4. Good job, team! Enjoyable experience and I will return.

Location

  • Pete's Pizza - New Richmond
    Pete's Pizza - New Richmond
    1230 N Knowles Ave, New Richmond, WI 54017, United States Hotline: +1 715-246-2633

Located in the heart of New Richmond, Wisconsin, Pete's Pizza - New Richmond offers a slice of comfort and tradition that resonates with both locals and visitors. Situated at 1230 N Knowles Ave, this pizza restaurant has become a staple for those seeking classic flavors crafted with care. Whether you're dialing in for take-out or choosing to dine in their cozy, reduced seating area, Pete's brings a warm, inviting atmosphere full of rich culinary history.

The menu highlights showcase a thoughtful balance of classic and inventive options. The Hawaiian Pizza stands out with its perfect harmony of sweet pineapple and savory ham, while the Buffalo Chicken Pizza delivers a bold, spicy kick that satisfies hearty appetites. For those craving variety, the Bacon Cheese Burger with Fries offers a hearty American staple done right, and the Spaghetti presents a comforting, well-sauced plate reminiscent of cherished family meals.

What truly sets Pete's Pizza apart is the thin crust, praised for its crisp texture and the depth of their well-seasoned sauce, a testament to years of perfected recipes. Regular customers speak highly of the consistent quality, noting how the pizza maintains its flavor even after years of loyal patronage. While the buffet has been retired, the restaurant's dedication to delivering delicious, familiar food remains unwavering.

Customer feedback reflects a strong community connection — from family gatherings steeped in long-time tradition to new memories being created with every visit. The staff’s helpfulness and genuine care enhance the dining experience, reinforcing Pete’s as more than just a pizza joint, but a local institution. Though some note missing elements, such as the distinctive fennel seed found in true Italian pies, Pete's approach appeals broadly with its balanced flavors and hearty portions.

In sum, Pete's Pizza - New Richmond is a place where nostalgia meets quality. It’s a flavorful stop on your culinary map that reminds you why local pizza shops hold a special place in our hearts. Whether you’re indulging in a classic Hawaiian slice or savoring the robust taste of their spaghetti, Pete’s promises a satisfying meal that tastes like home.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • Credit cards